BestFolio TAA Replication
Today’s post does two things: (1) looks at BestFolio and (2) replicates a black box TAA strategy using open models.
Bestfolio
BestFolio (BF) is a TAA Strategy integrator, similar to Allocate Smartly. I haven’t looked at it before.
At the time of writing, it runs 88 TAA strategies, mostly behind a $29 a month paywall. Yes, it’s US-based (it shows money in $ and € but not £, though it does have a tool for finding UCITS equivalents to US ETFs, where they exist).
The basic idea is that you browse through the strategies and put together a blend of strategies you like, with custom weights. Then BF sends you signals/target allocations at the start of the month.
This is similar to my own approach with TAA, except that I use Google Sheets (for free).
The site is nice and clean, and seems to offer decent dashboards.
You also get six strategies for free when you open an account. These are all fine, but obviously not the best that are available.
- In fact, at least three of the six look like fixed allocations to me (so not TAA at all).
There are also a couple of tools:
- The UCITS ETF finder, which I’ve already mentioned, and
- A Factor Lens (X-Ray) of your portfolio
The UCITS finder sounds good, but won’t be of any help when you discover that no UCITS equivalent exists (a weekly occurrence for me).
- Similarly, a factor X-Ray sounds neat, but you aren’t using TAA to get factor exposure.
On the other hand, it seems like a nice site and we could do with a backup to Allocate Smartly, so I wish them all the best.
- Apparently it’s also cheaper than AS.
Replication
As part of their marketing effort, BF makes posts on Reddit.
- In this case, a user called u/laurenthu (“I build BestFolio”) made a post back in July 2026 in a sub-reddit I watch called r/LETFs.
- It’s about leveraged ETFs, though I’m not sure the TAA strategies we’re about to discuss use LETFs.
A few days ago, a subscriber sent me an article where the author builds a portfolio on one of the paid strategy tracking platforms. [I guessed that must mean there are more than two in total, but in a comment reply, u/laurenthu admits that it’s from Allocate Smartly].
Three tactical strategies combined, and the combined numbers are genuinely impressive: about 16% a year since 1971 with a worst drawdown around -9%.
They asked if I could add the missing piece to my site. Except it’s a closed strategy. Its author gave the rules privately to the platform, the platform verified the track record, and the rules themselves stay secret.
So the idea was to figure out the rules and use the closest fit from the strategies on the BF website.
- In general, BF only lists strategies where the rules are public, so this would be progress.
Note that only one of the three strategies in the ensemble was secret.
- The other two were strategies that I use – Wouter Keller’s Bold Asset Allocation (BAA) and Hybrid Asset Allocation (HAA).
On the BF website, the article is attributed to the “BestFolio Research Team” (BFRT), which I must assume is u/laurenthu.
Solution
Somehow BFTR figured out that:
The closed strategy plays a specific role in that portfolio: fast momentum, heavily tilted to short lookbacks, quick to move the whole book to defensives at the first sign of weakness, about seven times the annual turnover of a typical monthly TAA model.
That sounds like the hard work done in one sentence, like the famous “how to draw a horse” tutorials, where the last step is to simply “draw the rest of the horse”.
- Later in the article, BFTR reveals that the public description of the black-box strategy says that it uses fast momentum.
All BFRT had to do was choose the closest model to that description on their site.
The closest public model we track in that spirit is Accelerating Dual Momentum, which scores assets on the average of their 1, 3, and 6-month returns and switches monthly.
ADM is another strategy that I use.
The monthly correlations between the three strategies (since 1986) are:
HAA to BAA 0.65, HAA to ADM 0.56, BAA to ADM 0.46. All three are tactical momentum models, so they rise together in long risk-on stretches, but they disagree often enough at the turns for a blend to have something to work with.
Results
The results aren’t earth-shattering, with only a slight improvement on HAA, the best of the three.
- Risk parity rather than equal weighting adds a touch of Sharpe but takes away a pinch of return.
But the path is smoother (as blends should be):
Each sleeve alone is respectable, and each has a real flaw. BAA and ADM both spent roughly three years underwater at their worst, and ADM’s 2022 drawdown reached -25%. The blend keeps nearly all of the return and roughly halves the worst drawdown.
In 40 years, the combined portfolio never lost more than 10.2% from a monthly peak. Its worst episode was August 1990, and it recovered in seven months. The global financial crisis cost it 9.0%; it recovered in five months. The one meaningfully negative calendar year was 2022, at -7.1%.
The blend is a bit worse than the black box target – lower return and volatility, but similar Sharpe and max drawdown.
The closed strategy trades far more actively than anything in our trio and apparently earns some real offense with it. Insisting on open rules costs you some return here.
Conclusions
I’m not sure I’ve learned much beyond the mechanics of the BF site, but I was bound to look at that sometime.
- I’ve also reaffirmed my commitment to TAA, and perhaps piqued your own interest in it.
That’s it for today.
- Until next time.








