Scottish Widows Retirement Report – record savings are not enough

Scottish Widows Retirement Report

We take a look at yesterday’s Scottish Widows Retirement Report, which finds that more people than ever are saving towards a comfortable retirement, but that it’s still not enough.

What is the report?

The Scottish Widows Retirement Report is an annual survey of the nation’s retirement saving habits that dates back to 2005.

The report looks at the percentage of men aged 30-64 and women aged 30-59 (with salaries above £10K pa) who are saving adequately for their retirement.

This year’s report is based on research carried out online by YouGov across a total of 5,191 UK adults over the age of 18 from March-April 2015.

What is enough?

The report defines adequate savings as either:

  • saving 12% of income, including employer contributions, or
  • having a main pension which is a defined benefits (DB) scheme – the so-called “gold plated” option (this is now around 20% of the population)

Note that these “adequate savers” will still experience a fall in their living standards in retirement compared to their working life.

The “replacement rate” (share of working income in retirement) for this level of savings is shown by working income level below:

replacement rate by income

Are we saving enough?

Not quite, though the results were the best ever, with more than half of savers (56%, up from 53% last year) putting enough away. Men were more likely to be saving enough (60%, compared with 52% of women).

For the first time, the average savings rate reached 12% of earnings. In 2006 this rate was 6% and in 2013 the average was 9%.

This partly reflects the rollout since 2012 of automatic enrolment into workplace pensions. The proportion of people remaining in these schemes (around 90%) has exceeded expectations. They are about to be rolled out to small businesses (10-49 employees) and it is hoped that this will lead to further improvement.

People are saving on average £142 a month, up 8% from £130 last year. Almost one in five (19%) expect to save more over the next year.

Despite the generally positive picture, one in five people (6.2 million) are still not saving anything for their retirement. This is the same level as in 2009. Two thirds of these say that they can’t afford to save anything.

A similar number (19%, up from 17% last year) have no savings or investments whatsoever.

Are savings evenly spread?

No.  Broken down by age, it’s no surprise that 62% of the over 50s are adequately saving.

But 50% of the over 50s are unlikely to save more in the next year, and around 10% think they have run out of time to make a difference. Around the same number (9%) are still prioritising debt repayment.

See also:  State of the Market - AltFi P2P Lending Review

money owed by age

Income also matters: 43% of those earning less than £10K pa are failing to save anything, compared to 24% of those earning up to £30K and just 9% of those earning more than £30K.

There was a big improvement in savings by 30- to 49-year-olds, 54% now saving adequately, compared with 42% only two years ago.

The self-employed and those working in small businesses are not doing so well, with 39% and 30% respectively not saving anything, up from 23% last year.

When do we want to retire?

expected retirement age

People would generally like to retire by the time they are 63, but are prepared to wait until 67.

How much income do we want?

income required by age

The average income people aged 30-65 would need to feel comfortable is £23.5K pa. However, people saving at the current average level can expect an annual income of £15.6K, an average shortfall of £7.8K.

income required by saver

How much do we think we need to have saved?

There is a big gap between how much people think they need to have saved by retirement, and how much they really need.

The average person thinks that they can produce their required income of £23.5K from a pot of £363K, whereas Scottish Widows (SW) think that £451K will be needed.

It’s interesting to note that the best savers have the best idea of how much money will be required.

savings required by saver

SW are including the state pension in their calculation. Given the rising state retirement age, this is an issue for anyone aiming at early retirement.

I would suggest that a safer calculation would ignore the state pension. In the current low-yield investment climate, a pot of more than £650K would be needed to safely produce £23.5K. This is almost double what people think that they need to save.

State pension expectations

anticipated state support

The government still has some work to do in publicising the new state pension which goes live in 2016. Across all age groups, people underestimate the level of the pension, which is £8K pa. ((It’s true that initially some people won’t have the 35 years of NI contributions / credits to claim the full pension, and also that the age of qualification will doubtless rise))

expected state pension by age

When do people start to save?

There is surprisingly broad agreement about the age at which people should start to save for retirement. Adequate savers begin at 28, and serious under savers at age 30.

While the extra two years will make a small difference, it’s clear that the message that pension saving is not just for the over-40s is getting through.

How do people feel?

Overall, around 40% feel positive about their short-term and long-term financial situation, up from 37% last year.

This varies by savings rate: more 50% of those saving adequately are optimistic, compared with less that 40% of under- and non-savers.

Do people understand the options?

understanding by age

Understanding of the available pension options is painfully low:

  • by age, it varies from 27% amongst the over 65s down to 4% amongst those in their 20s
  • by savings, it varies from 13% amongst adequate savers down to 10% amongst serious under-savers
  • by income, it varies from 26% amongst those on more than £50K pa down to 9% amongst those on less than £10K
See also:  Interactive Investor on Pensions

understanding by savings
understanding by income

Where will people go for advice?

advice by income

Looked at by income, those on higher incomes plan to use more professional advice, as well as the internet. Those on lower incomes are less sure what they will do.

Though more of the lowest income households would seek help from PensionWise than any other group, it’s still only 6%. Only 15% of the population were are aware of this service at launch.

advice by savings

Looked at by savings, the same trend is visible: those saving well will use advice and the internet, those not saving are less sure.

What do people want to do with their money?

decumulation options

The lack of understanding of pension options and questionable sources of advice are reflected in people’s preferred options for managing their money in retirement:

  • 33% want to take some cash in the early years, then buy an annuity
  • 11% plan to buy an annuity immediately
  • 9% plan to take all their money as cash immediately
  • 8% want to invest in buy-to-let
  • 26% don’t know
  • only 13% plan to use income drawdown

There’s quite a bit of work to do here on education people about the risks of taking cash and the poor value that annuities represent.

  1. Saving for retirement has reached record levels
  2. The average level of savings is now adequate, but there are wide variations across income and age groups
  3. People would like to retire early, but are prepared to wait until 67 (the current maximum state retirement age)
  4. The average income people require is £23.5K pa
  5. The average expected income is £15.6K pa, a shortfall of £7.8K pa
  6. People underestimate the amount of money they will need to have saved to produce their required income
  7. People underestimate the contribution to their retirement from the new state pension
  8. People still don’t understand the available pension options
  9. People are unsure about where to go for advice, and PensionWise does not figure highly
  10. 44% of people plan to buy an annuity, with only 13% planning to use income drawdown

Until next time.

Mike is the owner of 7 Circles, and a private investor living in London. He has been managing his own money for 40 years, with some success.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Scottish Widows Retirement Report – record savings are not enoug…

by Mike Rawson time to read: 4 min